Yaaaay i'm glad to hear I was wrong! Mudclaw definitely should be in Starclan. Not sure where I had the idea he wasn't… huh.
oh yeah totally, having an evil clan founder would be really neat, especially when it ISN'T the shadowclan founder. poor shadowclan has such a bad reputation, orz ;__; I'll keep reading, hopefully by the end of the arc he'll have a more definitive character! he has potential, for sure.