Jilda
The erins try to hard to force us into liking certain cats (like Crowfeather by still displaying him as “decent” when he's pretty crappy) and hating some (like Mudclaw). idk, they try to make it seem like in their books sometimes its either black or white with who's evil and who's good but that shouldn't be the case.
I'm glad Mudclaw is in StarClan though!